4 responses to “Viewers’ Guide to Prop 8 argument December 6”

  1. MikeA

    At least 1 factual mistake:
    You write that “The August 4 decision from Judge Vaughn Walker was the first time a federal court had struck down a statewide same-sex marriage ban”.
    But it wasn’t the 1st time.
    In 2005 another federal judge (Joseph F. Bataillon) made similar ruling, which was reversed by 8th Circuit Appellate Court.

  2. Anonygrl

    A major difference between these two cases is that Nebraska never had allowed same sex marriage, but for the space of several months, California did, and 18,000 couples took advantage of it. So this case is quite different as it deals with rights that were at one time granted, then taken away, whereas the Nebraska case did not.

  3. Guy Noir, Private Eye

    I think Cooper’s presentation was ‘just short of pathetic’…
    He seemed to Stumble & Stammer when asked questions, IMHO, he just wasn’t prepared.
    Olson, OTOH, was well prepared, AND: it Counts!

    Cooper’s reasoning was Weak, Olson’s was Strong.

    I believe P8 is DEAD, only waiting for the Grave to be Covered…

Leave a Reply

Your support keeps us going. Thank you!

Your support keeps us going. Thank you!

A Closer Look

GOP field: split on Kim Davis, NOM pledge; agreed on Planned Parenthood

  While the many Republican presidential hopefuls hold similar positions on LGBT-related issues, the past two weeks has seen them begin to distinguish themselves in some ways. For instance, during the past two weeks, five said they believe Kentucky county clerk Kim Davis has a religious freedom right to deny marriage licenses to same-sex couples, […]

» more

Breaking News

Fiorina shines, Bush ‘contorts’ to the right, Walker and Perry are gone

People posting on the Log Cabin Republican’s Facebook timeline last Wednesday night overwhelmingly agreed that business executive Carly Fiorina was the winner. But not everyone was praising Fiorina after the debate.

» more

Supreme Court denies stay in Kentucky clerk bid to refuse marriage licenses

In a significant blow to those who seek to use a free exercise of religion argument to discriminate against same-sex couples seeking to marry, U.S. Supreme Court on Monday evening denied an emergency request to stop enforcement of a federal district court order that a Kentucky county clerk resume issuing marriage licenses.

» more

Cruz says gay florist should be able to refuse service to evangelical

Republican presidential hopeful told a gathering last Friday that a gay florist should be able to refuse service to an evangelical couple if the florist disagrees with the couple’s faith.

» more

Religion v. equal protection showdown reaches 6th Circuit

An important showdown between the constitutional rights to religious freedom and equal protection reached a federal appeals court Tuesday (August 18). A county clerk in Kentucky filed an appeal to the Sixth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals in hopes of securing the right to refuse marriage licenses to same-sex couples.

» more

Kasich gets a small boost, but debate does little to change GOP standings

Republican presidential candidates’ responses on LGBT questions during the August 6 debate appear to have had very little impact on the candidates’ overall standings in the polls. Ohio Governor John Kasich, who won some positive commentary for his remark that he’d love his daughter even if she was gay (that wasn’t the question), picked up […]

» more