ad_facebook
ad_facebook_468

One response to “Prop 8 appeal heading to full circuit”

  1. Sam

    Due respect, but you’ve missed one INCREDIBLY important detail. En banc rehearings don’t just happen simply because someone asks. There are fairly strict criteria that must be met before the full Circuit grants rehearing. Even if we set those criteria aside, backers of Prop 8 will have to convince a majority of active judges on the Ninth Circuit that there’s a real need to do this all over again. Considering that Randy Smith, probably THE most conservative judge on the Circuit only barely sided with Prop 8 supporters, there are probably a lot of conservatives on the Circuit who won’t want to repeat this exercise. As for the liberals and moderates, they constitute a majority of the Ninth Circuit, and there’s a strong possibility they won’t want to take the chance of an en banc panel overturning this one. A rehearing is far from a done deal here.

Leave a Reply

Your support keeps us going. Thank you!

Your support keeps us going. Thank you!

A Closer Look

First GOP debates: 17 candidates, one ‘humane’ response on LGBT issues

Only six of the 17 Republican presidential candidates fielded a question that hit upon an LGBT issue during last Thursday’s debates. And only one of those six –Ohio Governor John Kasich— answered in a way that suggested a measure of respect for LGBT people.

» more


Breaking News

Cruz says gay florist should be able to refuse service to evangelical

Republican presidential hopeful told a gathering last Friday that a gay florist should be able to refuse service to an evangelical couple if the florist disagrees with the couple’s faith.

» more


Religion v. equal protection showdown reaches 6th Circuit

An important showdown between the constitutional rights to religious freedom and equal protection reached a federal appeals court Tuesday (August 18). A county clerk in Kentucky filed an appeal to the Sixth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals in hopes of securing the right to refuse marriage licenses to same-sex couples.

» more


Kasich gets a small boost, but debate does little to change GOP standings

Republican presidential candidates’ responses on LGBT questions during the August 6 debate appear to have had very little impact on the candidates’ overall standings in the polls. Ohio Governor John Kasich, who won some positive commentary for his remark that he’d love his daughter even if she was gay (that wasn’t the question), picked up […]

» more


EEOC decision gives concrete remedies for federal employees facing bias

A U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission decision Thursday could provide important remedies to thousands of federal workers who might face sexual orientation discrimination and may increase pressure on Congress to advance the ENDA.

» more


“Justice that arrives like a thunderbolt”: On same-sex marriage “the fight is over”

June 26 has been solidified as the historic date for LGBT history in the United States. It is the day in 2003 when the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that states could not enforce laws prohibiting same-sex adults from having intimate relations. It is the day in 2013 when a Supreme Court procedural ruling enabled same-sex couples to marry […]

» more